Coinbase Advance Trading
complete
M
Modern Bison
Coinbase recently launched advanced trading
The trades are not showing up in Koinly correctly, they show up as withdraw and deposit without showing the fee.
You can get these details on their api:
L
Linen Raven
I synced my Coinbase wallet to do Tax Report and it's showing yellow exclamation mark "GBP balance doesn't match what you have on your wallet. The balance calculated from imported transaction for this coin is HIGHER than your actual balance by 0.2 GBP".
I had a detailed look at transaction history on Coinbase and what Koinly imported via their API.
Coinbase is rounding GBP amount it deducts from GBP balance to 2 decimal points for each "fill" in advanced trade.
However, it's reporting reporting many more decimal points via API.
Koinly is adding up GBP cost of fills first and then rounding for the whole advance trade.
This different rounding causes the fiat balances in Coinbase and Koinly to be slightly different and it may increase over time.
Robin
Merged in a post:
Coinbase Advance Trading - Orders with multiple fills are reporting the entire transaction amount based on only one of the fills.
J
Jonquil yellow Harrier
Hello,
Since I started using the new Coinbase Advance Trading platform this past month I've noticed Koinly started reporting issues when syncing my Coinbase activity.
After looking into this I determined that certain transactions are being completed through multiple fills. For example let's say I place a market order for 5 ETH. Coinbase might fill this order with 4.5 ETH @ $2500 and 0.5 ETH @ $2501. Koinly seems to pick up only one of these fills and then reports that I only bought 0.5 ETH and ignores the other fill.
Below are some screenshots of an example ALGO order I placed that has this issue. You can see that Koinly is reporting an amount of ALGO missing that equals the amount of 1 of the 2 fills. I had a similar issue with CRO hence the other misreported balance.
J
Jonquil yellow Harrier
I believe this issue was resolved as part of the fix for https://feedback.koinly.io/bug-reports-public/p/coinbase-advanced-trading-not-imported-correctyl
I had to completely delete my coinbase wallet and reimport to fix the issues. Simply syncing from the beginning did not correct it.
Thanks for the fix!
C
Commercial Fish
Yep, this is causing a whole bunch of issues for me as well. Same circumstances (2 fills on Coinbase, only first one is read by Koinly, can't manually fix amount in Koinly because API syncs cannot be modified).
L
Lavender Gecko
Same issue. I'm deleting these incorrect/synced transactions and manually creating transactions with correct values. Please fix this issue. I'm paying to avoid this manual work :-(
V
Vivid Antelope
I don't think this should be set as complete. I just did 4 advanced trading transactions and all 4 of them are wrong. The problem I found is that advanced trading does the trades a separate fills and not one transaction and Koinly is pulling parts of it, but not the whole transaction.
O
Oyster Antelope
Same issue with me as well
G
Gamboge Marsupial
Seeing the exact same issue here
M
Misty rose Shrew
So excited to see this completed! I tested this out with an Advanced Trade this morning, and it is indeed much better, but still not quite reconciling with Coinbase. Fees were off by $0.01035857 (before this support fees were off by more like $0.80, so huge improvement!). Obviously this is not a huge deal, but I would love to have things reconcile exactly so that I don't have to manually fix up. Please holler if you'd like any details from me re: costs and fees I'm seeing on the coinbase side vs. what Koinly picked up from their use of the Coinbase API. Thanks!
C
Controlled Tuna
Misty rose Shrew: Yeah, I don't know if the rounding error is from Coinbase or Koinly, but someone's rounding things off where they shouldn't. Didn't happen with Coinbase Pro before they upgraded trading on Coinbase proper.
This post was marked as
complete
Load More
→